Pricing convictions make the shelf-to-till check a management issue

Share Article

Two supermarket convictions reported on 30 October underline the need to test what the customer is actually charged.
Christchurch coffee shop product shelving

The Commerce Commission reported on 30 October 2026 that two Pak'nSave supermarkets had been convicted and fined a combined $580,500 for inaccurate pricing that breached the Fair Trading Act. The Commission said the cases concerned repeated pricing errors that misled customers.

For other retailers, the practical issue is the connection between the displayed offer and the amount charged. A promotion can be carefully designed and still fail at the point where labels, product records and checkout settings meet. Checking only the head-office price file does not test that whole journey.

A useful audit starts where a customer starts. Select a modest sample of products from the shop floor, record the displayed price and conditions, then check the checkout result. Include ordinary stock as well as promotions, and test situations that staff know can be awkward, such as several similar pack sizes beside one offer. Keep the sample manageable enough to repeat.

When an error appears, correct the customer-facing issue and investigate its source. Was a label left behind, a product attached to the wrong promotion or a system update applied incompletely? A record that simply says fixed gives the manager little to prevent a recurrence. Record the underlying cause and identify whether other items may share it.

An illustrative homewares retailer might find that a weekend offer ends in the system while signs remain on one display. Its response could include allocating the removal task, confirming completion and checking that a replacement sign has not been missed. The point is to make the transition visible, rather than rely on someone remembering which display was changed.

Staff also need a clear route when a shopper raises a discrepancy. Identify who can resolve the immediate transaction, how the issue is reported and who checks the wider display or product group. A single customer complaint may reveal a broader operational problem, so the information should reach the person who can investigate it.

The Commission's announcement discusses potential changes to the Fair Trading Act as proposals. Retailers should keep proposed penalties separate from the law currently applying. The present lesson does not depend on guessing the outcome of reform: businesses need their displayed prices and checkout systems to work accurately now.

For owners, a short regular price check can be treated as an operating control alongside opening procedures and stock security. Review repeated causes, rather than only counting the number of corrections. That gives the business a better basis for improving the process and helps ensure that a customer buying an ordinary item receives the offer the store has actually made.

ads-2

Explore Business Topics

Whether you’re running a business, growing your career or simply staying informed, discover expert articles from New Zealand’s most important industries.

Accounting

Tax, bookkeeping, Xero, payroll and financial reporting.

Agriculture

Farming, agribusiness, horticulture, innovation and rural industry news.

Construction

Building, trades, regulations, projects and construction industry updates.

Engineering

Engineering innovation, infrastructure, manufacturing and technical expertise.

Finance

Business finance, investing, lending, insurance and economic insights.

Health

Healthcare, medical services, wellbeing, aged care and industry developments.

Law

Commercial law, employment law, property law and legal guidance.

Logistics

Supply chains, warehousing, fulfilment, freight and logistics solutions.

Property

Commercial property, real estate, investment and market trends.

Retail

Retail trends, eCommerce, customer experience and business growth.

Technology

Artificial intelligence, cybersecurity, software and digital transformation.

Transport

Road, rail, marine, aviation and transport industry developments.